4A THE UNIVERSITY DAILY KANSAN GOVERNMENT NEWS GOVERNMENT TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 29, 2005 Lawyer argues over financial disclosure BY MARK SHERMAN THE ASSOCIATED PRESS WASHINGTON—As a Justice Department lawyer, Samuel Alito quarreled with the head of the government ethics office over proposed requirements on personal financial disclosures, according to documents released Monday. Alito's 1987 letter was issued around the time the ethics office said his boss, Attorney General Edwin Meese III, had violated financial disclosure requirements over a $60,000 investment with a businessman who was tied to Wedtech, a Bronx, N.Y., defense contractor that was caught up in a wide-ranging federal investigation. There was no suggestion that Alito, now nominated to be a Supreme Court justice, was aware of the ethics office's issues with Meese's disclosure. Alito's letter to David H. Martin, director of the Office of Government Ethics, was among 120 documents from Alito's service as the deputy assistant attorney general in the Office of Legal Counsel from 1985 to 1987 that were released by the Justice Department in response to a Freedom of Information Act request from The Associated Press and other news organizations. Alito became the U.S. attorney for New Jersey after leaving Justice headquarters and then was appointed to the federal bench. President Bush has nominated him to replace retiring Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O'Connor. Some of the material in the newly released documents was blacked out for privacy reasons. An additional 60 documents were withheld because they contained classified information or confidential exchanges between government lawyers and their clients or for other reasons, said Paul B. Colborn, special counsel in the office where Alito worked. In his February 1987 letter, Ali- to, who served as his division's ethics officer, faulted Martin for failing to consult with the Justice Department before publishing proposed regulations on financial disclosures that upper-level government officials must submit annually. "In this case, the need for such consultation was acute, since we made it abundantly clear to your office ... that we had serious legal objections," Alito wrote. The proposal increased the number of federal employees who would have to disclose their finances. In the same period, the office was reviewing Meese's own report for 1985, which obscured how W. Franklyn Chinn invested the $60,000 Meese gave him, the ethics office said. Chinn, Meese's former financial adviser, later was convicted in the Wedtech scandal. Meese never faced criminal charges. The documents generally paint a picture of Alito as a lawyer who gives great deference to governmental actions. A September 1986 memo to the FBI, for instance, recommends that the bureau ignore a federal court decision restricting Education Department jobs that should require full background investigations for prospective hires. "The district court's opinion ... is subject to two interpretations, neither of which has a sound legal basis," Alito wrote of a ruling by U.S. District Judge Louis Oberdorfer. A January 1986 letter to then-FBI Director William Webster concludes that the bureau may add to its files fingerprints, supplied by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, of Afghan and Iranian refugees without raising privacy concerns. In another memo, dated January 1987, Alito raised concerns about a ban on capital punishment and other child welfare provisions that were part of a proposed international treaty on children's rights, noting that states, not the federal government, regulate those areas. BUSINESS Pedestrians walk past a store window display along State Street on Monday in Chicago. Some of the nation's retailers reported a strong opening to the crucial holiday sales period last weekend, but other merchants said shopper traffic fell back once Friday's bargains passed. Stores may start sales early BY ANNE D'INNOCENZIO THE ASSOCIATED PRESS Now that the Thanksgiving weekend is over, how much will shoppers see in the way of markdowns — and how soon? Monday started the quiet time for the holiday season at the nation's traditional retailers, and it was also the official start to the holiday period for online merchants. With fewer shoppers in the stores, many nervous merchants will be tempted to start extreme discounts early, beyond the markdowns already planned for the season. Perkins, president of Retail Metrics LLC, a research firm in Swampscott, Mass. "If the traffic drops off a cliff, then stores will have to be more proactive. There were some clear lessons from last weekend. If you have bargains, then shoppers will flock to your store. If not, they will be more reluctant." "My sense is that stores will take stock of how the weekend went and see how the first week progresses," said Ken Amid an improving but still challenging economy, many retailers offered discounts over the weekend that were even more aggressive than at the start of last year's holiday season. But overall, the weekend's results were sluggish, according to ShopperTrak RCT Corp., which monitors sales at more than 45,000 retail outlets and reported that sales for Friday and Saturday combined fell 0.5 percent from the same period a year ago. The big winners were discounters including Wal-Mart Stores Inc. and electronics chains, which attracted shoppers in the early morning hours Friday with discounted digital cameras and TVs. Mid-price stores like J.C. Penney Co. Inc., and Kohl's Corp., which also plied shoppers with early openings and big discounts on sweaters, pulled in the crowds as well. But plenty of other mall-based apparel stores were left behind, except for teen stores such as Abercrombie & Fitch Co., which has been able to attract a loyal following without having to resort to such measures. Meanwhile, in cyberspace, free shipping and heavier price cutting that started early in November has helped lure shoppers, said Heather Dougherty, an analyst at Nielsen/NetRatings, an Internet research firm. According to comScore Networks Inc., consumers spent $305 million online on Friday, up 22 percent from $250 million a year earlier. But Monday was seen as the real beginning of the online shopping season, and so retailers were offering even better deals. The University of Kansas Chapter of All-academic honor society is proud to announce new member initiates Phi Kappa Phi 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, Nov. 29, Woodruff Auditorium (initiates should assemble at 5 p.m. in the Jayhawk Room) Keynote speaker: Chancellor Robert E. Hemenway Congratulations to the 2005 Phi Kappa Phi initiates, KU's Best! Faculty Richard T. DeGeorge Department of Philosophy Mary Lee Hummert Department of Communication Studies Philip A. Schrodt Department of Political Science Students College of Liberal Arts & Science Kelly Abrams Laney Allbritten Emily Andrezik Jason Arribas Damien Baranski Travis Barnicle Joshua Baruth Katey Birge Trevor Blattner Tyler Bron Valerie Chermok Larissa Ejazk Hannah Fiechtner Miles Garrett Abbie Gilmore Dennis Golden Angela Gray Jennifer Grode Megan Higley Nicole Holmes Cody Hoss Susan Johnson David Jones Tracy Jones Heasuk Kim Yujie Li Christopher Lintecum Bridget Livers April Lorrett Lindsey Matson Anne McEnroe Steve Munch Suong Nguyen John O Donnell Andrew Payne Brian Pitts Sridhar Reddy Tricia Rock Lindsey Rohwer Devdeep Sarkar Matthew Schoonover Tara Schupner Daniel Stanhope Kyle Stearns Zachary Taylor Blair Thompson Lucas Thompson Luis Vargas Alice Walkiewicz Christine Walters Travis Warner Mark Webster Sean Whittier Karyn Wilson Meredith Winner Lucas Wohlford Richard Yang School of Architecture & Urban Design School of Allied Health Arjun Bhat Justin Dorsey Matthew Keys Andrew Wright Kimberly Hadley Patrick Harper Kara Hopkins Christina King Nancy McKenna School of Business Jacquelyn Bowlin Weng Hong Chan Kristin Conklin Allison Dietrich Kimberly Elliott Ryan Gehbauer Ji Hong Todd Kitchens Stephanie Kot Joseph Loner Edwin Mitchell Joseph Onofrio Olivia Pfannenstiel Charles Rose Dave Shandler Scott Shorten Lauran Smith Tad Thompson Jennifer Worthington School of Education Michael Faggella-Luby Jill Hundley Tina Shea Karrie Shogren Nina Zuna School of Engineering Kyle Adams Samer Adra Susan Enneking Daniel Flanigan Jake Foiles Julie Goehring Amanda Harris Mehrdad Hosni Rebecca Huff Travis Johnston Benjamin Ku Mei Liu Russell Mailen Mark Mattione Todd McDonald William Miller Katherine Molstad Tristan Moody Laura Nolle Jon Novak Heather Owen Grant Robertson Angela Sanders Braden Sutton Brent Uhrig Andrew Wooten School of Fine Arts Meghan Bahn Brian Bondari Brett Ebeling Steven McDonald Gregory Ramsdell Meggi Sweeney School of Journalism & Mass Communications Daniel Blom Tamara Dugard Kayvon Sarraf Kaitlan Shamet Lauren Taylor Ashley Thompson School of Law Jacob Hecker Christopher Reed Kristen Van Saun School of Nursing Shanna Albright Mary Alfonsin Patricia Alingh Stephani Almai Susan Andersen Kelsey Bryaver Sarah Bryant Danelle Hake Katie Hall Kristin Hall Brenda Hollander Carol Kemper Tona Leiker Janice Smith Julie Smith School of Social Welfare Lisa Crook Sandra Culig Grace Hoyt Christopher Veeh T lege journ in a cause roles very integ in it port. I the l but edito inqu veal attitu camp In was a ney C ance e lege F was o Jonath 864-48 ▼ T/ Austin 864-48 Joshua 864-485 Matthee 864-492 Sarah 864-40 John M 864-446 1 Malcolm adviser 864-766 Jennifer adviser 864-766 1 +