Tuesday, October 24, 2000
The University Daily Kansan
Section A • Page 5
Ruling challenges free speech
Those who post libelous messages must be named
The Associated Press
MIAMI — In a ruling that challenges online anonymity, a Florida appeals court declared Oct. 16 that Internet service providers must divulge the identities of people who post defamatory messages on the Internet.
Critics of the ruling say it could have a chilling effect on free expression in Internet chat rooms.
The ruling comes against the efforts of the American Civil Liberties Union to protect the identity of eight individuals who posted anonymous missives on a Yahoo financial chat room about Erik Hvide, the former chief executive officer of Hvide Marine Inc. Hvide alleges that personal attacks against him also caused damage to the company's image.
Hvide's attorney Bruce Fischman hailed the ruling and said it would force Internet users to think a bit before they speak.
The ACLU had wanted the court first to rule on whether Hyde had
actually been defamed before identifying the defendants, named in court papers only as John Doe. If there was no showing of defamation, the ACLU reasoned, the critics should remain anonymous.
However, on Oct. 12, the court dissolved a stay freezing subpoenas for the records of Yahool Inc. and America Online Inc., whose service was used by one of the defendants in the defamation case.
Lauren Gelman, public policy director with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, is concerned that other courts could follow the lead of the 3rd District Court of Appeals in approving subpoenas.
"This kind of speech happens all the time in all kinds of chat rooms," Gelman said. "We don't want to see these subpoenas become regularly used to cause people to self-censor themselves."
Both Internet companies took a back seat if the lawsuit, saying they would do whatever the judges said.
Lyrissa Lidsky, who argued the ACLU's case, called the decision a surprise and a setback.
Nevertheless, she said it was not a defeat for all the other John Does fighting Internet-related subpoenas because the court did not explain its legal reasoning.
“This kind of speech happens all the time in all kinds of chat rooms. We don't want to see these subpoenas become regularly used to cause people to self- censor themselves." Lauren Gelman Electronic Frontier Foundation
An appeal is being explored. "The court had the potential to set an important precedent about the right to speak anonymously on the Internet," Lidsky said. "The courts are eventually going to have to come to grips with this issue and decide how broad free speech rights are in cvberspace."
The issue is largely untested in the nation's courts.
the nation's courts. A Virginia federal judge sided with a government subpoena request in a criminal case, but civil suits in California and Virginia have not settled the subpoena questions involving anonymous Internet users.
There are those who shy away from challenges. And then there are those who travel 9,000 miles looking for them.
Stop by a Peace Corps Information Session and find out about the hundreds of overseas jobs awaiting you!
www.peacecorps.gov 800-424-8580
University of Kansas
INFORMATION TABLE:
Wednesday, October 25th
10:30 am - 4 pm
Kansas Union, 4th Floor Lobby
FILM SHOW:
Wednesday, October 25th
5:30 pm
Kansas Union, Centennial Room
RETIREMENT INSURANCE MUTUAL FUNDS TRUST SERVICES TUITION FINANCING
TIAA-CREF provides financial solutions to last a lifetime.
Building your assets is one thing. Figuring out how those assets can provide you with a comfortable retirement is quite another
At TIAA-CREF, we can help you with both. You can count on us not only while you're saving and planning for retirement, but in retirement, too.
Just call us. We'll show you how our flexible range of payout options can meet your retirement goals.
With TIAA-CREF, you benefit from something few other companies can offer. a total commitment to your financial well-being, today and tomorrow.
*Note: Availability may depend on your employer's retirement plan provisions contract. Under federal tax law, withdrawals prior to age 59 may be subject to restrictions, and may also be subject to a 10% additional tax. Additional restrictions also apply to the ITAA Traditional Annuity.
With TIAA-CREF,
you can receive:*
- Cash withdrawals
- Systematic or fixed-period payments***
- Interest-only payments
- Lifetime income payments**
- A combination of these
**Guaranteed by our claims-paying ability
CREF Growth is one of many CREF variable annuities
Ensuring the future for those who shape it.
1. 800.842.2776 www.tiaa-cref.org
For more complete information on our securities products, please call 1 800 842 2733, ext. 5509, to request prospectuses. Read them carefully before you invest. 1. Due to current market volatility, our securities products' performance today may be less than shown above. The investment results shown for CREF Growth variable annuity reflects past performance and are not indicative of future rates of return. These returns and the value of the principal you have invested will fluctuate, so the shares you own may be more or less than their original price upon redemption. * TIAA-CREF Individual and Institutional Services, Inc. distributes the CREF and TIAA Real Estate variable annuities. * Teachers Personal Services, Inc. distributes the Personal Annuities variable annuity component, mutual funds and tuition savings agreements. * TIAA and TIAA-CREF Life Insurance Co., New York, NY, issue insurance and annuities. * TIAA-CREF Trust Company, FSB provides trust services. * Investment products are not FDIC insured, may lose value and are not bank guaranteed. © 2000 TIAA-CREF 08/03