KANSAN.COM / THE UNIVERSITY DAILY KANSAN / WEDNESDAY, JULY 7, 2010 / NEWS
19
Judges order two newspapers to delete archived crime stories
ASSOCIATED PRESS
STATE COLLEGE, Pa. - Two newspapers want a state judge to overturn an order requiring them to delete archived stories and other information about two defendants, cases that touch on the potential for media censorship.
Such orders typically direct public agencies to clear a person's record in cases in which charges are dismissed or withdrawn or aren't applicable for someone who's a first-time offender who completes a rehabilitation program.
The Centre Daily Times and The Daily Collegian student newspaper at Penn State were ordered to expunge records of information about the defendants, an unusual provision inserted by a defense lawyer into otherwise standard orders signed by Centre County Judge Thomas King Kistler.
Attorney Joseph Amendola told the Times he included the newspapers in orders for five defendants, including the two before Kistler, because he was concerned the media's First Amendment rights to free speech were trumping his clients' rights to have cleared records. It's common for attorneys to draw up legal documents for judges to consider.
Centre County Judge Bradley Lunsford, who handled the three other cases, cited free speech concerns Tuesday in signing new expungement orders, submitted by
a newspaper lawyer, that rescinded an order on Friday. The new order did not require the newspapers to expunge information about the defendants, including news stories.
"Oh, my, yes. There's definitely a First Amendment issue," Lunsford told The Associated Press on Tuesday in a phone interview before he signed the new order.
Kistler, who received similar proposed revised orders from a newspaper lawyer, said he wanted to schedule a meeting this week with county President Judge David Grine and Amendola before taking further action.
"What's the sense in having your record expunged if anyone can Google you and it comes up?"
"I want to see at this meeting what the outcome is from the defense lawyer that prepared these and see why it's in there," Kistler said. "Certainly we want to get it squared away. We have a very good relationship with all the media in Centre County, and we want to do what the statute requires."
Newspapers increasingly are getting requests from private citizens asking for archived stories to be deleted out of fear, for instance, that a potential employer may find damaging information on the Internet.
archives that are factually correct, and an expungement of court records doesn't mean the events never occurred, said Melissa Bevan Melewsky, a media law attorney for the Harrisburg-based Pennsylvania Newspaper Association.
Newspapers ultimately are under no legal obligation to change
"It's accurate when it was reported, and that means there's nothing illegal about it," she said. "It's protected speech."
Joseph Amendola Attorney
Amendola did not immediately return phone messages from the AP seeking comment Tuesday. He told the Times this was a national issue bigger than the newspaper and judges.
"What's the sense in having your record expunged if anyone can Google you and it comes up," he was quoted by the newspaper as saying. "Ultimately, this is an issue that needs to be decided by the legislature."
Copies of the initial orders including the newspapers were not available publicly because those documents are covered under the expungement guidelines, a county court clerk said.
The Centre County judges usually sign 30 to 50 such orders at a time once or twice a week. The orders are vetted by the probation department and the district attorney's office
before going to a judge to approve that outside agencies follow suit.
In the five cases, orders initially directed records of information to be expunged — as with public agencies — but did not specify to the newspapers what that entailed.
Kistler and Lunsford said judges typically don't read the text of each order and assume the orders are consistent with law. The orders are "certainly not things that we, as judges ... create. They're created by lawyers," Kistler said.
Lunsford said his new orders, first submitted for approval by Times attorneys, also rescinded a mandate that a private website that allows the public to search criminal records also expunge information.
Defense lawyers may be frustrated about the availability of information on the Internet, Lunford said.
"But what they don't realize from the court's perspective, we only have jurisdiction over government offices that play a part in the prosecution of a particular individual, and no one else," Lunsford said.
The Times had published short stories on the cases of two defendants, while the other three cases appeared in weekly court reports. Executive editor Bob Heise likened archived stories to historical records of facts, which aren't altered.
"I appreciate (Lunsford) acting as fast as he could to straighten this out." Heisse said. "It's very clear that it was on the wrong path."
CRIME
Missouri boy charged in parents'murder
KAISER, Mo. — A 12-year-old mid-Missouri boy has been charged in juvenile court with two counts of first-degree murder in the shooting deaths of his mother and stepfather.
The 26th Judicial Circuit's chief juvenile officer, Tammy Walden, told The Associated Press on Tuesday that a hearing will be held later to determine whether the boy will be tried as an adult or juvenile.
Miller County Sheriff Bill Abbott says police found the bodies Monday night in a mobile home park in the small Miller County town of Kaiser.
Authorities aren't identifying the boy because of his age. The adults' names are being withheld while relatives are notified.
Associated Press
Neighbors say the boy lived in the home with five other children, but none of the others were there at the time of the shooting.
pipelineproductions.com
Fri July 9
BRODY BUSTER Band
Sat July10
J WAIL
w/ Rocket Science
Thurs July 15
CHUCK MEAD
w/ Ricky Dean Sinatra
Tues July 20
FRONTIER RUCKUS
w/ Samantha Crain
BOTTLENECK
737 New Hampshire
thebottleneclive.com
Verizon Wireless Concert Series
Thurs July 8
THURS JULY 8
GRACE POTTER
and the Nocturnals
DAR WILLIAMS
SARA WATKINS
CARRIE RODRIGUEZ
JULIA PETERSON
Fri July 16
$ELLOUT!
w/The Zeroes
Thurs July 29
OLD 97's LUCERO
Jonathan Tyler & N.Lights
Fri Aug 6
Thurs Aug 12
BETTER THAN EZRA
SLIGHTLY STOOPID CYPRESS HILL COLLIE BUDDZ
Thurs Aug19
GEORGE
THOROGOOD
Fri Aug 27
BIG HEAD TODD
w/BoDEANS
Fri Sept 3 PAT GREEN
Sun Sept 5
STS9 w/Ghostland Observatory
Sat Sept 25
AVETT BROTHERS
Sun Oct 3 BLUE OCTOBER
verizon 417 E. 18th·KC, MO
www.crossroadskc.com